Delays raise concerns about Loop 202’s necessity - Ahwatukee Foothills News: Topstory

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

Delays raise concerns about Loop 202’s necessity

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Tuesday, March 16, 2010 11:00 pm

Editor’s Note: This is the second in an occasional series outlining some of the issues surrounding construction of the South Mountain Loop 202, from Interstate 10 in Ahwatukee Foothills, west through South Mountain Park and then north to reconnect with I-10. Click here to see the first installment," target="_blank" title= "“Air pollution a concern for critics of Loop 202.">“Air pollution a concern for critics of Loop 202."


Mike Lograsso says that, if he must, he can pack up his belongings and move faster than the average Ahwatukee Foothills resident.

He and his wife, along with their dogs, occupy a modest house on Redwood Lane, an entry-level development of about 70 homes just north of Pecos Road. It is one of the few neighborhoods in Ahwatukee Foothills that stand in the direct path of the proposed South Mountain Freeway and, as a result, homeowners like Lograsso are faced with the possibility that the state will one day purchase their property and force them to relocate.

When that day will come, however, is anyone’s guess.

“The state has informed us of nothing,” Lograsso said. “We’re all sitting here saying, ‘Give us a yes or no answer, anything but a maybe.’”

Construction of the eight-lane freeway, which would either demolish these homes or place them behind a concrete sound barrier, could begin as soon as 2013, so private buyers for the properties are scarce and reluctant, and residents here are wary of spending more money on their homes than is required for general maintenance for fear they won’t recoup their investments.

“We’re forced into this limbo stage where we’re not sure we’re going to get out of the house what we put into it,” Lograsso said. “And until we have a definitive answer it’s almost impossible to sell our home.”

Across the street, Debra and Mike Thake say they have held off installing a swimming pool in their backyard. After owning their home for 10 years, they, too, are wondering if they’ll be properly compensated for renovations and improvements if the state ultimately decides to buy them out. Like most residents living here, the Thakes were made aware that a government right of way could one day displace them. While the freeway proposal predates the development, the exact location and imprint of the freeway weren’t always made clear.

“I bought this house to raise my kids, and I wasn’t worried about it back then,” Debra Thake said. “Now I am.”

“If they got it now we would lose,” Mike Thake added, expressing his concern that what the state deems fair market value may be priced well below what he and other owners here expect to be paid.

Since its conception in 1985, the South Mountain Freeway – or the Loop 202 as it is otherwise known – has been suspended, redesigned and publicly disputed numerous times. Its long and complex developmental history has some critics questioning its necessity, especially during an economic recession.

“They’ve been trying to package this freeway for years,” said Laurel Arndt, a faculty associate at Arizona State University’s School of Geographic Sciences and Urban Planning and a former member of the South Mountain Citizens Advisory Team. “It would be very embarrassing for them to say ‘You know what? Everyone else is right, and we’re wrong.’ That will never happen.”

But members of the Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT) and the Maricopa Association of Governments (MAG), the two agencies responsible for the freeway’s design and construction, cite the growing problem of traffic congestion along existing east-to-west corridors – such as Interstate 10 – as reason enough to press on.

“A lot of folks say that our models are outdated,” said Bob Hazlett, senior engineer with MAG. “But the numbers are still there, and the congestion is still there. So the real need for the freeway is still there.”

A 2003 study conducted by the U.S. Census Bureau projects the population of Maricopa County to increase by approximately 50 percent – from 4.15 million to 6.24 million – over the next two decades, according to data posted on ADOT’s Web site. Such an increase in drivers will place and added strain on an already overwhelmed traffic system, Hazlett says.

But this projection, aside from being outdated, tells only a portion of the whole story, said Arndt, who insists that a recent shift in the federal government’s transit philosophy toward moving people rather than cars should be practiced in the Valley.

“For them to continue to shove these numbers from five years ago down our throats is really disingenuous,” Arndt said. “The critical thing is to forecast with other modalities of transportation in mind. All I suggest is that you give people options and choices, and right now in Arizona we have no choices. We have a car.”

Proponents of the freeway acknowledge that mass transit is an ideal solution to traffic congestion in the Valley, but that many commuters will be disinclined to exchange their cars for a seat on the bus.

“The South Mountain Freeway is not going to solve all of the regional transportation problems,” ADOT spokesman Tim Tait said. “But it is largely viewed as the missing link in the loop system between east and west that is so desperately needed.”

The problem also may be environmental. Efficient public transportation systems are more difficult to implement in sprawling cities such as Phoenix, according to Hazlett.

“The only way that public transportation really works is if you have sufficient enough densities to make it happen,” he said. “We’re not New York City. We live in the West where people like to spread out.”

Still, Hazlett insists that MAG is developing mass transit in the Valley where it is needed and economically prudent.

“We’re making a number of public transportation improvements,” he said. “But despite those improvements, we still need South Mountain Freeway.”

While ADOT continues to address a freeway budget deficit of $6.6 billion, Tait has said there is enough funding available to begin construction of the South Mountain Freeway should a route be decided upon and approved. The department is working with the Nebraska-based private engineering firm HDR to develop a draft environmental impact statement to be released next year.

In the meantime, homeowners on Redwood Lane, like Robert Martinez, anxiously await a formal decision from the state while doing just enough work on their homes to keep them from falling into disrepair.

“I’m basically maintaining it; I’m not letting it go,” Martinez said. “I bought this house with the intention of staying here.”


Ahwatukee Foothills resident Robert Oppermann is interning this semester for the Ahwatukee Foothills News. He is a senior at Michigan State University and can be reached at

More about

More about

More about

  • Discuss

Macayo's rebrands, changes name (for the fourth time in 70 years)

Macayo's, the long-standing Mexican restaurant whose original owner Woody Johnson is credited with inventing the chimichanga, has gone through…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:45 pm @…

Emerging Garden and Plant Trends for 2017

To boost sales next year, dig deep into these consumer desires. by: Tom OderBoost your lawn and garden sales by knowing the 2017 trends. (Phot…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:45 pm @…

Goodyear Kid Science Advisor meets Obama to talk about STEM

Local 13-year-old Sage Foreman, who represents his Goodyear school as a chief science officer for the Arizona SciTech Festival, recently visit…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:43 pm @…

Poll: Donald Trump takes the lead in Arizona

PHOENIX - A new poll shows Donald Trump has taken the lead in Arizona. The poll released by Monmouth University on Tuesday shows 46% of Arizon…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:41 pm @…

Ballot Bullies: Big Tobacco Goes All Out to Kill Proposition 56

Photo by Pandora Young The old-school image of a rock star was a guy smoking a cigarette, and Tris Imboden was that guy. As the drummer for th…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:14 pm @…

Brewer tells the truth

The national progressive echo chamber had quite a fit last week when former Gov. Jan Brewer brushed off the suggestion that Hispanics would ca…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:14 pm @…

Latino Activists Respond to Jan Brewer's 'They Don't Vote' Remark

Griselda Nevarez A A Did Jan Brewer put her foot in her mouth this past Friday? A lot of Arizona Latinos think so.  In an interview with the B…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:01 pm @…

Hugging Higher Costs

Yesterday, the Obama Administration announced 2017 premium increases averaging 25 percent for the benchmark plan offered on the federal ObamaC…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 3:44 pm @

Mock teen bedroom at AZ capitol shows hidden signs of drugs

By Andres Guerra Luz | Cronkite News PHOENIX – It seems like a normal room: There’s a can of hairspray by the mirror, a red trash can by the d…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 3:40 pm @…

Former Sparky keeps fork 'em tradition in family

For Trisalyn Nelson, inspiration hit when the oncoming car almost did. One day in 2014, Nelson was cycling on her way back from work at the Sp…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 3:10 pm @…

Facebook on Facebook

Twitter on Twitter


Subscribe to via RSS

RSS Feeds


Most Popular

Online poll