Conceding there have been several recent "high profile'' deaths and near deaths of children, the director of the Department of Economic Security promised Friday to make changes in how complaints are handled.

Clarence Carter told Capitol Media Services that senior staffers have come up with a plan that should cut the time for doing the average investigation to about 40 days. That, he said, compares with anywhere from 178 to 203 days for typical cases.

A pilot project using the new protocols is set to begin at the end of month. Carter said once the bugs are worked out and the system is implemented statewide, it should free up enough time to be the equivalent of 96 full-time staffers, making a big dent in the ability of Child Protective Services, which is part of DES, to investigate more complaints, and more thoroughly.

He said that does not mean CPS workers will be cutting corners, saying that the new protocols will eliminate "redundancy and documentation that doesn't add value'' to investigations.

Carter, hired to direct DES by Gov. Jan Brewer earlier this year, said meetings with senior staffers showed him the entire process is overly burdensome.

"We just add new policies and regulation on top of old and we tell the worker that all of it's important,'' he said.

"But the truth is, some of the new (rules) made the old obsolete,'' Carter continued. "And we never took the old away.''

Some of what will be done is still in the works.

Carter said staffers found 459 reports that were identified as open investigations where there had been at least three prior reports of child or abuse or neglect in the past 24 months.

He said staffers have evaluated those cases and identified the ones that require immediate attention. Still to be developed, though, is a process for how new reports of child maltreatment with multiple prior "engagements'' by CPS will be reviewed.

Carter also promised to improve the "transparency'' of Child Protective Services.

But Friday's report contains no mention -- and no release of records -- of what Chandler police said was a "near-death episode'' of a baby girl earlier this year due to "injuries (that) were non-accidental trauma.''

Arizona law requires CPS to make public information in cases of child abuse, abandonment or neglect that resulted in a fatality of near fatality. But the agency has turned down public records requests for the report.

Carter said, though, the doctor who did the evaluation for CPS concluded that, despite what is in the police report, her injuries were not life threatening. The director said that leaves him bound by normal rules of confidentiality.

Dana Naimark, president of the Chidren's Action Alliance, said she had not seen the report which was made public after 5 p.m. on Friday.

But Naimark, told of some of what was in the report, said it appears to gloss over one key fact: state lawmakers order CPS in early 2009 to cut its budget, leaving it up to the agency how to save money. the result was more than 100 caseworkers in training losing their jobs.

Carter, in his report, made no mention of those 2009 layoffs, saying instead that as of the end of last year his agency was authorized to have 1,043 CPS employees.

"However, only 844 positions were filled due in part to the lack of qualified applicants applying for those positions,'' he said. Carter said the management of DES, which oversees CPS, has made filling the vacant position "a priority in developing the CPS workforce.''

Carter acknowledged that the layoffs may have created some temporary problems for the agency, which he said has a turnover rate of CPS caseworkers of about 20 percent a year, a figure he said is about even with the national average. But he said that, even with those layoffs, the number of caseworkers actually on the job now is the highest it has been in three years.

Naimark, however, said the problem of cases going without proper investigation -- and children under CPS protection being injured or dying -- will never be solved without providing CPS with more resources.

Carter's promises include at least one item aimed strictly at public relations: He said he will use "social media, as appropriate, to communicate with the public.''

At the same time the DES report was made public, the governor signed an executive order creating a Child Safety Task Force. She wants a report by the end of the year on "statutory, organizational, management or protocol reforms'' to improve the safety of children under state supervision.

(1) comment


I have not been in Arizona for long, nor have I had to deal with child abuse issues until now. As the new Step Mom of a beautiful 12 Year old daughter, I am sorely disappointed in not only the Police Dept, CPS, and the court system. Everything sides with the abuser, the child is not listened too. Physical abuse needs to leave blood and bruises, emotional, verbal, mental abuse (with the proven long term damage) is all but ignored. One would think that if a child is crying out for help, a victim of domestic violence, and it has been ongoing for 4 years, that someone, somewhere would take notice.
Instead the parent who has the best interest has to be wary of being guilty of parental alienation toward the abuser, spend alot of money that could go to the child's education, home and welfare on the legal system, lawyers and usually for a fruitless endeavor.
As the non abusive part of the family our only choice is to keep fighting the battle, filing reports, and calling the police for a worthless incident report. As someone who loves a child, all you can do act everything the abusers draw a new line in the stand, knowing that they will once again get away with the behavior.
The children? They learn to trust no one, that no one will believe them, come to their aid, and the police will not believe or protect them. They are told to call 911...but why? All that comes from that is to be left with the abuser and suffer more abuse for crying out for help.
I used to believe, and respect in the protections put in place for children. I used tho think if you called for help or taught your child to call for help, that the victim would be protected. I taught my child that lesson. I'm sure the system will finally work, they will work when they are dealing with a bleeding, irreparably damaged child. As for Child Protection should be removed, they do little to prevent or protect. At least from the point of view of an outsider who is watching the damage happen.
Someone...take a moment will you...listen to child!

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.