How to make your opponent pay your legal fees - Ahwatukee Foothills News: Money

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

How to make your opponent pay your legal fees

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Brian Foster

Related Stories

Posted: Thursday, May 17, 2012 3:01 pm

In Arizona there are very few instances when the winning party in a dispute can make the losing party pay the attorneys’ fees and other costs spent by the winning party. One of the instances when this is allowed is in contract disputes.

The law in Arizona is that if you are the prevailing party in an action “arising out of contract,” the court may make the losing party pay some or all of your attorneys’ fees and other costs spent in prevailing. See Arizona Revised Statute 12-341.01(A). This attorney fee recovery provision applies to both verbal and written contract disputes.

As you might expect, sometimes questions arise regarding who the “prevailing party” is in a contract dispute. For example, if you sue someone for $1,000 and recover $100 are you truly the prevailing party?

Or, if you prevail on a contract claim but lose on all of the other seven non-contract claims, are you truly the prevailing party?

To help make determining who the prevailing party is easier and to encourage parties to settle disputes, the Arizona Legislature enacted a statute that provides that you are the prevailing party if you make a written offer to settle a contract dispute that is rejected and at trial you are awarded an amount greater than the amount you offered to settle, A.R.S. 12-341.01(A).

In other words, if you make a written offer to settle for $100 and at trial you are awarded more than $100, you are the prevailing party and will recover your attorneys’ fees from your opponent. By the same token, if you are the defendant in the case and offered to settle for $100 and the judge or jury awards your opponent $90 at trial, you will be the prevailing party and the other side will have to pay your attorneys’ fees even though the other side recovered $90 from you. So even though you lost the case the other side has to pay your legal fees, which may be larger than the $90 they won.

The offer must be in writing and you are only the prevailing party from the date of your offer forward. So it’s in your best interest to make a written offer early on in a dispute to maximize your legal fees that your opponent must pay.

I recently completed a three-week jury trial in a large business and real estate dispute that had been litigated for five years. The case involved 15 different claims, some of which were breach of contract claims.

Before the lawsuit was filed I encouraged my client to make a defensive written settlement offer, which they agreed to make. Our settlement offer was rejected and for the next five years the parties actively litigated this dispute culminating in a three week jury trial in April.

At trial, the plaintiff recovered nothing on his multiple claims and my clients recovered millions on their counterclaims, including misrepresentation and breach of contract claims.

Because my clients made a written settlement offer five years ago (which was rejected), my clients are the prevailing party and the losing party will have to pay my client’s attorneys’ fees, which in this case are extremely high.

The moral of the story is that if you have a verbal or written contract dispute, you should give serious consideration to making a written settlement offer early on in the case even if it is for an amount you know the other side will not accept. That way if you have to litigate you can make the other side pay for your legal costs.

• Brian Foster is a 20-year Ahwatukee resident and senior partner at Snell & Wilmer L.L.P. in Phoenix. Reach him at (602) 382-6242 or

More about

More about

More about

  • Discuss

Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio formally charged with criminal contempt

According to the Arizona Republic, Sheriff Joe Arpaio has been formally charged with criminal contempt. U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton signe…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 5:41 pm @…

Time for a Face Off Between the Cubs and Indians

A worker prepares a banner along the dugout a day before game one of the World Series between the Chicago Cubs and the Cleveland Indians at Pr…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 5:29 pm @…

Arizona and Georgia: Not swing states

Contributors feed By Scott McLean, contributor Last Monday, the Clinton campaign announced that it would invest $2 million in advertising in t…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 5:22 pm @…

Macayo's rebrands, changes name (for the fourth time in 70 years)

Macayo's, the long-standing Mexican restaurant whose original owner Woody Johnson is credited with inventing the chimichanga, has gone through…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:45 pm @…

Goodyear Kid Science Advisor meets Obama to talk about STEM

Local 13-year-old Sage Foreman, who represents his Goodyear school as a chief science officer for the Arizona SciTech Festival, recently visit…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:43 pm @…

Emerging Garden and Plant Trends for 2017

To boost sales next year, dig deep into these consumer desires. by: Tom OderBoost your lawn and garden sales by knowing the 2017 trends. (Phot…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:45 pm @…

Poll: Donald Trump takes the lead in Arizona

PHOENIX - A new poll shows Donald Trump has taken the lead in Arizona. The poll released by Monmouth University on Tuesday shows 46% of Arizon…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:41 pm @…

Ballot Bullies: Big Tobacco Goes All Out to Kill Proposition 56

Photo by Pandora Young The old-school image of a rock star was a guy smoking a cigarette, and Tris Imboden was that guy. As the drummer for th…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:14 pm @…

Brewer tells the truth

The national progressive echo chamber had quite a fit last week when former Gov. Jan Brewer brushed off the suggestion that Hispanics would ca…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:14 pm @…

Latino Activists Respond to Jan Brewer's 'They Don't Vote' Remark

Griselda Nevarez A A Did Jan Brewer put her foot in her mouth this past Friday? A lot of Arizona Latinos think so.  In an interview with the B…

Published: October 25, 2016 - 4:01 pm @…

Facebook on Facebook

Twitter on Twitter


Subscribe to via RSS

RSS Feeds


Most Popular

Online poll