Conservative justices or primitive justices? - Ahwatukee Foothills News: Commentary

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
|
||
Logout|My Dashboard

Conservative justices or primitive justices?

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Thursday, July 9, 2009 11:00 pm

In a 5-4 decision that exemplifies their basic contempt for genuine justice, the Supreme Court’s politically reactionary majority rejected a prisoner’s request for DNA testing that could prove his innocence after 14 years’ imprisonment on a possibly false verdict for rape.

In the most appalling aspect of this decision, Chief Justice Roberts agreed with Alaskan prosecutors that a DNA test could definitively determine the prisoner’s guilt or innocence. In his ruling opinion, he nonetheless saw “no necessity for a ... far-reaching constitutional right of access to this type of evidence.”

In other words, don’t confuse the courts with scientific facts.

The Supreme Court heard this case (District Attorney’s Office v. Osborne) after Alaskan prosecutors appealed a federal appellate court order to allow the requested DNA test. The appellate judges sensibly ordered the test to resolve the prisoner’s dubious guilty verdict. Osborne agreed to pay for a DNA test of semen retained since commission of the 1994 crime (why did Alaskan officials retain this evidence if they intended to bar its use)?

Over the past 15 years, Cardoza University’s DNA-based Project Innocence has won 240 exonerations of falsely convicted prisoners. In 103 cases, guilty, but unconvicted perpetrators were identified for corrective prosecution.

These overturned verdicts have exposed documented instances of prosecutors’ racism, lethargy, corruption and sheer stubborn stupidity. They have also demonstrated the extreme fallibility of eyewitness identification.

Many prosecutors fight access to DNA evidence, even in the majority of states that allow it. Concern for their damaged reputations often outweighs prosecutors’ dedication to justice.

In one preposterous case before the Missouri Supreme Court, prosecutors argued that a convict should be executed even if DNA evidence proved his innocence. Some lawyers display a dedication to the sanctity of the judicial process even if it produces monstrous injustice.

Justice Samuel Alito buttressed Roberts’ opinion with a warning that court orders for DNA testing could induce prisoners “to play games with the criminal justice system,” drowning state courts in a flood of testing demands. States would incur significant costs, argued Alito, in a typical conservative exploitation of the slippery-slope fallacy.

In another irrelevant comment, Justice Alito appeared to contradict the Chief Justice’s admission that in this case DNA testing would definitively determine a just verdict. Alito claimed that even the most sophisticated DNA testing “often fails to provide absolute proof of anything.” If he disagreed with the Chief Justice, why didn’t he say so?

In the four dissenting justices’ rebuttal, John Paul Stevens denounced Alaska for refusing all DNA testing requests. He attacked the majority decision with this sensible conclusion: “There is no reason to deny access to the evidence, and there are many reasons to provide it.”

In this outrageous violation of common sense, the five “conservative” justices rejected constitutional principles of due process, the demands of simple justice and a soundly reasoned appellate court decision. The word to describe these troglodytes is not “conservative;” it is “primitive.”

 

C.W. Griffin has lived in Ahwatukee Foothills since 1988. He is a retired consulting engineer and a published author.

More about

  • Discuss

Phoenix man, Gregorio Villanueva, accused of stealing $10,000 in electricity

PHOENIX - While the rest of us are sweating to pay our electric bills, a Phoenix man is accused of stealing his for nearly three years. Court …

Published: July 25, 2016 - 2:56 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/crime/phoenix-man-gregor…

Dr. Brook Larson named Arizona Choral Director of the Year

Dr. Brook Carter Larson, artistic director of the Orpheus Male Chorus of Phoenix, has been named Choral Director of the Year by the Arizona Ch…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 2:54 pm @ http://www.scottsdaleindependent.com/news/dr-brook…

Fight between driver, passenger results in crash on SR 51 in Phoenix

PHOENIX - Police say a car crash that critically injured a driver and shut down part of a Phoenix freeway was started by a fight between the m…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 2:53 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/region-phoenix-metro/cen…

What to expect at the Democratic National Convention

The first day of the Democratic National Convention began on Monday, July 25, in Philadelphia, a little after 4:00 pm Eastern. The convention’…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 2:29 pm @ http://www.vox.com/2016/7/25/12268364/watch-dnc-de…

ACLU Praises New Illinois Limits on Cellphone Surveillance

A new Illinois law limits how police can use devices that cast a wide net in gathering cellphone data and are at the center of a lawsuit again…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 1:59 pm @ http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/wireStory/aclu-pr…

Arizona State University Athletics

TEMPE, Arizona—The Arizona State University football team, under the direction of fifth-year Head Coach Todd Graham, will make its annual trek…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 1:59 pm @ http://www.thesundevils.com/news/2016/7/25/sun-dev…

FD: Three people rescued from Echo Canyon including 12-year-old boy

PHOENIX - Three people had to be rescued at Camelback Mountain on Monday afternoon including a 12-year-old child. The Phoenix Fire Department …

Published: July 25, 2016 - 1:56 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/region-phoenix-metro/cen…

Toro Y Moi Shares New “Grown Up Calls” Video, Announces Tour: Watch

Chaz Bundick (aka Toro Y Moi) has a new live album, Toro Y Moi: Live From Trona, out August 5. Today, he’s shared the video for the album’s “G…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 1:27 pm @ http://pitchfork.com/news/67059-toro-y-moi-shares-…

“A Lady for President?” Third Graders Respond

In January, 1964, Senator Margaret Chase Smith, of Maine, entered the New Hampshire primary, becoming the first woman to run for a major-party…

Published: July 25, 2016 - 1:25 pm @ http://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/a-la…

Women found dead in apparent Phoenix murder-suicide

PHOENIX - Officials are investigating a murder-suicide in Phoenix. Phoenix police said on Saturday morning they responded for a check welfare …

Published: July 25, 2016 - 12:55 pm @ http://www.abc15.com/news/region-phoenix-metro/sou…

Facebook

ahwatukee.com on Facebook

Twitter

ahwatukee.com on Twitter

RSS

Subscribe to ahwatukee.com via RSS

RSS Feeds

Spacer4px

Most Popular

Online poll

Loading…