Taxpayers have a right to know how many illegal immigrant students are in public schools - Ahwatukee Foothills News: Commentary

default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

Taxpayers have a right to know how many illegal immigrant students are in public schools

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Monday, July 20, 2009 11:00 pm

I authored Senate Bill 1172 to require all Arizona school districts to count and report yearly their illegal alien students and seven legislators joined as co-sponsors. I was sorry to read Beth Lyon’s July 10 letter (“Federal law doesn’t ask student’s immigration status”) that centered on non-issues and personal attacks rather than the bill’s provisions and true intent; the cost – one billion dollars or more? Why would Beth be afraid to let the taxpayer know the real cost?

Such letters do damage beyond just adding insults and ill will to what should be a discussion of facts; Arizona taxpayers also lose an opportunity. It’s appalling that the author’s attacks are based on what she “guesses.” Ironically, it’s those who call for “civil dialog free of personal attacks” who mount attacks on others.

As the bill’s author, I’d like to emphasize what are the issues and more importantly, what ARE NOT.

It is not about excluding students from school, students’ English fluency or their skin color.

It is about holding a school board accountable for its past track record, written and published in a newspaper. The track record consistently shows passing up the chance to seek federal reimbursement for school costs of illegal aliens that fall heavily on border-state taxpayers.

School boards have long excused refusing to count and report numbers of illegal alien students by reciting a myth that “federal law prohibits a school from asking a student’s immigration status.” I did extensive research on this question before submitting SB1172. There is no such federal law! Even the U.S. Supreme Court verdict in the 1982 Plyler v. Doe case doesn’t forbid asking. The mantra is just plain false.

By misleading citizens with a false “federal law,” elected school board members robbed taxpayers of the chance to pursue federal reimbursement or understand the real impact. Some may not care. After all, schools are paid based on the number of students no matter where they come from. 

We already have programs like SCAAP in place that recover federal money for Arizona’s costs to jail illegal aliens, as well as the unpaid medical care that EMTALA requires we provide regardless of immigration status. While we don’t collect 100 percent of the expense, it’s better for Arizona taxpayers than no reimbursement at all.

SB1172 would be a first step to add education costs to recovered federal dollars. But school officials refuse to collect the specific numbers required by such programs. Those same school boards then tell taxpayers they can’t recover the money because “there are no accurate numbers.”

Elected school board officials are obligated to serve the interests of all citizens, not just students and school district employees. But they turn their backs on Arizona taxpayers by following the easier (for them) choice of raising taxes rather than risk being politically incorrect.

When school boards unilaterally decided to forfeit the opportunity to keep more of our own money, they did a disservice to Arizona taxpayers.

School boards seem determined to continue evading the issue. Their “federal law” has been exposed as false, yet they don’t want to serve taxpayers’ interests by seeking money in new places. They want to throw in the towel because they’re sure it will fail, but they can’t be sure without trying. Arizona’s taxpayers deserve that from the school board members they elect. And taxpayers have a right to know how their money is spent.

The governor’s extended budget objections prevented SB1172 from completing the process before adjournment.

But it will be re-introduced next session, and I urge school boards to cooperate: identify your “federal law” so it can be investigated and concerns resolved, or admit that it was a non-issue from the start. Fish or cut bait.

Taxpayers have a right to know.


Sen. Russell Pearce (R-Mesa) is a retired Maricopa County Sheriff’s deputy and longtime lawmaker. He can be reached at

More about

More about

More about

  • Discuss

Environment Canada shy about announcing contract for upgraded weather radar

The federal government has quietly awarded an $83-million contract to outfit Environment Canada with a new national network of weather radar s…

Published: December 8, 2016 - 6:36 pm @…

Pearl Harbor survivor: What I saw aboard the USS Arizona on December 7, 1941

Editor's note: The following column is adapted from "All the Gallant Men: An American Sailor's Firsthand Account of Pearl Harbor." I was aboar…

Published: December 8, 2016 - 1:55 pm @…

Pearl Harbor: 5 survive; 2 will join fallen USS Arizona shipmates

HONOLULU — As the afternoon shadows lengthen at Pearl Harbor on Wednesday, four Navy veterans will gather aboard the USS Arizona Memorial for …

Published: December 8, 2016 - 12:54 pm @…

Scottsdale Fashion Square announces big renovation plans

Enhancements to Luxury Offerings Will Be First Phase; Louis Vuitton Announces Major Store Renovation in 2017   Macerich, one of the nation’s l…

Published: December 8, 2016 - 11:47 am @…

Climate Change Expected To Hit Arizona At Higher Intensity

Published: Wednesday, December 7, 2016 - 11:06amUpdated: Wednesday, December 7, 2016 - 11:05am

Published: December 8, 2016 - 11:23 am @…

Masked man sought after armed robbery at Mesa Econolodge Inn and Suites

MESA - Mesa police are looking for the man behind a Halloween mask during an armed robbery of a hotel last week. According to police, the mask…

Published: December 8, 2016 - 11:17 am @…

The Top Travel Specialists in the World

If you read Condé Nast Traveler, chances are you want to go somewhere and do something most people haven’t. And to turn a vacation into an I’l…

Published: December 8, 2016 - 11:16 am @…

Broadway actor to headline Arizona Musicfest benefit performance

Broadway actor Brent Barrett will highlight an evening celebrating and supporting Arizona Musicfest’s excellence in artistry and philanthropy …

Published: December 8, 2016 - 8:48 am @…

US Border Patrol uses desert as ‘weapon’ to kill thousands of migrants, report says

The US Border Patrol agency has engineered the death and disappearance of tens of thousands of undocumented immigrants by using the desert wil…

Published: December 7, 2016 - 5:22 pm @…

Architect Helps Shape City's Growth Through Collaboration

More than a decade ago architect Mark Ryan frequently had to drive to go out to lunch from his office space in Roosevelt Row.

Published: December 7, 2016 - 2:40 pm @…

Facebook on Facebook

Twitter on Twitter


Subscribe to via RSS

RSS Feeds


Most Popular

Online poll